
I've been mulling this question over for months ever since an interesting convo with my philosophy prof.
How are Santa Clause and God alike?
How are they different?
Which is better, in your opinion? and WHY?
This is all hypothetical- you don't have to believe in either one to answer. Just use the qualities typically attributed to them by popular culture.
I think Santa Clause is better because he gives gifts and doesn't expect anything in return. He demands no worship, no adoration, no thank-you cards. He just gives gifts.
I think Santa Clause and God are alike in that no one I know has ever seen either of them (the ones at the mall are just his helpers). I have never been to where they live (Heaven or the North Pole) or seen any of their helpers (elves or angels). Both supposedly know when you are sleeping, when you are awake and whether you are bad or good.
I think they are different in that no one has ever started a war over anything to do with Santa Clause. Kids usually stop believing in Santa Clause at some point, but many kids, if they ever did believe in God, keep believing in God. They are also different because God has control over the weather, laws of nature, time and human interactions whereas Santa Clause is at the mercy of weather (he got Rudolf to light his way because he couldn't see in the fog). No one goes to foreign countries to try to convince peopleto believe in Santa Clause. I don't know of anyone who has ever been killed for believing or disbelieving in Santa Clause.
They both, however, take over the radio, stores and malls for one month every year!
Chatboard (0)