The Reluctant SingerA Traveler's Thoughts
About this Entry
Posted by: thereluctantsinger

Visit thereluctantsinger's Xanga Site

Original: 6/14/2006 12:00 AM
Comments: 15
eProps: 14

Read Comments
Post a Comment
Back to Your Xanga Site



Wednesday, June 14, 2006
 

Is Power the Ultimate Motivation?

At first, I was tempted to answer this question with a resounding yes. But that passed in a few microseconds. Why? Because the word ultimate suggests that it is at the very core of everything we do and all other reasons for our actions reduce themselves, in the end, to this one reason - power. I cannot accept that suggestion, because there are too many things that do not reduce themselves to either power in my view.

Love, for example. I do not fall in love so that I can exercise power over my lover, nor does genuine love result from any expectation of economic gain. I do not love my children because I can exercise power over them, and they are more of an economic liability than a gain, at least for the first 20 and some odd years of their lives. Oh, it is true that they or their children or their grandchildren may one day become an influential members of the community, but that is not why I have them. In most cases such influence will not transfer any power or glory to me.

And what about those who are motivated to self-sacrifice. A man on a battlefield will sometimes fall on a grenade and give his life to save the lives of his buddies. He can have no expectation of economic gain or acquisition of any power as a result of his action.

Fear also is a powerful motivator, even more so than power itself. Why, because when it comes to a man’s life, in almost every case, a man will give up power rather than die. His life becomes more important.

Hate, too, is a powerful motivator. A man may be so bent on revenge for some insult or injustice, that he will commit a murder before witnesses, knowing in advance that he will go to prison for life. Someone might argue that such a man is exercising power over his victim, and that is true as far as it goes. But the fact is that such an individual doesn’t care about the power he exercises over his victim. That is not his motivator. He only cares about seeing to it that his victim dies. His motive is revenge.

And let's not forget sex as a motivator. It can be used as a power weapon, but for most people it is either a selfish physical gratification, an expression of love, or a simple desire to please, more than power that drives people to it.

Power is a strong motivator, to be sure. And I suppose there are some people who seek power as it’s own reward. But more frequently, power is sought to achieve some other end, usually economic. Wealth! Greed! The lust to have things! These are the real motivators behind power.

We can argue that economic wealth is used to achieve power. We can also argue that power is used to achieve wealth. Which came first? They clearly work together, each chasing the other in a vicious circle, but my observation suggests that while some individuals are motivated by power alone, most are not, and neither are nations.

Individuals can pursue things for the pleasure of doing so. The world as a whole, however, is motivated by economics. If there isn't a dollar in it, it's not worth pursuing. People and Nations won't fight a war or explore new trade routes, etc., unless there is an economic advantage to doing so, because power without eonomic advantage has no value, unless survival itself is at stake. We don't empty our coffers; we seek to fill them.
 Posted 6/14/2006 12:00 AM - 15 comments

Give eProps or Post a Comment

15 Comments

Visit Simone_De_Beauvoir's Xanga Site!
Linking you now.
Posted 6/14/2006 1:05 AM by Simone_De_Beauvoir Xanga Premium Member - reply

Visit Pheebles's Xanga Site!

I don't think that power is the ultimate motivator either. For me, most of the time, love is the ultimate motivator. I don't even see money as a huge thing for myself. I like to have it, in order to pay my bills and buy food and clothing, but it is not the most important thing for me.

I will do things for the sheer love/pleasure of them, including emptying my purse for charity.

Shalom!

Posted 6/14/2006 2:05 AM by Pheebles Xanga True Member Xanga Lifetime Member - reply

Visit SkyMarshalOz's Xanga Site!
I would like to say love is my greatest motivator. That is what I wish it was. I wish my motivation came from the more noble and virtiuos characteristics, but in looking at my actions and attitudes, I have to say that often times, my motivation is self-gain and gratification. I am ashamed to say that most of my unselfish acts are done for reasons other than love. I usaually do those sort of things for the same reasons the pharisees did. To bolster other people's opinions of me and boost my own ego. I am not a greedy person though. I don't care much for money. Power on the other hand is a big part of it all. It doesn't seem too outragous to state that above all other things I really do desire power. But, in realizing these things, I can better combat them. I can through a conscious effort and through prayer work against these things. I can and am being conformed to the likeness of Jesus. My motivations are changing. My heart is changing, and even if it won't be in this life, I know I will one day reach the point where my heart will be pure. Where my actions will be based in virtue instead of vice.

I tend to agree with J.R.R. Tolkien, "Above all else men desire power." While man has other desires, overall I believe that man's greatest desire is for power. Man, like Lucifer, desires to be god. To have power and control over themselnes and over all other things. Other motivations are generally subject to it. Some instincts like those controlling desire for sex and survival can overide it temporarily, they also do seem in the end to be subject to it. Offspring, is often a way to gain power, or to pass on that power once your life has faded.
Posted 6/14/2006 5:14 AM by SkyMarshalOz - reply

Visit anniemomz's Xanga Site!
Great post. You present your answer to the topic clearly and succinctly. Extreme logic used to expound upon what I think is a psychological question boggles my mind. I do think, as I said in my post, that love is the greatest/ultimate motivator. Seems to me that is what everyone is chasing - even love of self - which is what wanting power is all about.

Peace.
Posted 6/14/2006 11:45 AM by anniemomz - reply

Visit eddiefromhb's Xanga Site!
Can the world as a whole be motivated in a way distinct from the people who make up that world?  Are group motivations independent of the members of the group?  At what level does economics motivate individuals to contribute to the global concern for economic stability/success?
Posted 6/14/2006 4:16 PM by eddiefromhb - reply

Visit thereluctantsinger's Xanga Site!
eddiefromhb: Can the world as a whole be motivated in a way distinct from the people who make up that world?

The world is made up of a collection of groups called nations. The nations are motivated by economics, specifically the economic wellbeing of its citizens. Individual citizens are generally motivated by several things. They must eat and pay bills, so survival is a factor. Beyond that, people will be motivated by whatever makes them feel good. For some it is a need to feel loved, or at least needed; for others it is a need for adventure, still others just want to feel safe.
Posted 6/14/2006 4:49 PM by thereluctantsinger - reply

Visit thereluctantsinger's Xanga Site!
anniemomz: Thanks.
Posted 6/14/2006 4:52 PM by thereluctantsinger - reply

Visit cgdp001's Xanga Site!
RYC:  I haven't heard anything from her either....I thought that maybe she was on vacation or something because she had mentioned spending some time relaxing in her previous entry..... let me know if you find out anything :)
Posted 6/14/2006 11:57 PM by cgdp001 Xanga True Member - reply

Visit cgdp001's Xanga Site!
This entry is very interesting.  I would like to say that the biggest motivator in my life is love.  I suppose it really is, moreso than anything else, but the thing I probably need to work on is letting that be more obvious.   I think the motivation for lots of people is just simply that they feel the need to be RIGHT all the time.  Drives me crazy.
Posted 6/15/2006 12:59 AM by cgdp001 Xanga True Member - reply

Visit thereluctantsinger's Xanga Site!
cgdp001: I think the motivation for lots of people is just simply that they feel the need to be RIGHT all the time. Drives me crazy.

There is a lot of going on these days. And it is frustrating.
Posted 6/15/2006 10:28 AM by thereluctantsinger - reply

Visit tychecat's Xanga Site!
Once, when i was young, I spent a long slow voyage to Europe and back arguing Marxian social theory with the ship's radio operator - a card-carrying communist. (I was the only one who would sit with him during meals). I must say, the experience was fascinating and stood me in good stead years later when I was teaching the required "Americanism vs Communism" course to HS juniors.
Marx, of course, put all his eggs in the economic basket claiming that greed for economic power was the dominate force driving our era of history. The brave new world he proposed was supposed to be the natural progression into the next (and better) age .He was unusual, in that his basic philosophy got a 70+ year field trial in the real world and was pretty much proven incorrect.
Apparently the chief motivating factor in people is not one absolute, rather it seems to vary from person to person. I suspect LOVE in all its facets, would be the majority winner.
Posted 6/15/2006 11:53 AM by tychecat Xanga Premium Member - reply

Visit wegotrhythm's Xanga Site!

Fabulous post......you've brought this discussion to a full rounded view, touching on so many parts of what can motivate us - and power to control another, as Webster defines, does not have to enter the equation.  In fact, it can reduce our capacity as human beings to that of only animal instincts, and I believe in my heart, we are of a greater connection to each other than that.  My question:  why does one feel the need to have power over another as any type of motivation to do good in this life?  You've brought so many beautiful points to the readers. 

Thank you for sharing with so much depth, your views. 

Lisa.

Posted 6/15/2006 1:19 PM by wegotrhythm Xanga Premium Member - reply

Visit thereluctantsinger's Xanga Site!
wegotrhythm: Thank you for your kind words.

why does one feel the need to have power over another as any type of motivation to do good in this life?

Power is not necessarily something that one wants in order to do good in this life, though it can be for that reason. But all too often it is a matter of greed. Power can allow someone to manipulate other people in order to add to their wealth. Power allows U.S. Congressmen to pass laws which many believe will be beneficial for a large number of people, but some congressment, don't care about the majority of the people. They will sell their vote. So many reasons people crave power. But in the end, I think it will come down to survival. After survival, love for one's fellow man is high on this list. That is followed by wealth beyond what is needed to survival.
Posted 6/15/2006 7:23 PM by thereluctantsinger - reply

Visit wegotrhythm's Xanga Site!

Again, you stretch my thoughts to see, perhaps on a higher plane, as once mankind's own survival needs (a hut to protect us from the weather, food to energize our cells, and perhaps the need for procreation is taken care of (??) as you have mentioned - perhaps it is then, "But in the end, I think it will come down to survival. After survival, love for one's fellow man is high on this list"  is a truisim of mankind - 'love for one's fellow man is high on this list.'

I am a bit cynical when it comes to this ending, because I believe that mankind looks for love not from his fellow man, nor respect, nor so much intimacy, but looks for his own reflection in that mirror that hangs on his wall as he shaves or she applies her make up.  Very cynical outlook, I know, but am just reflecting the stage in life wherein I see people in their 50's striving to not go good for the world, inasmuch as do good for themselves.....

(Please remember, I am writing this from the perspective of a woman who has not had a real vacation in years, and the woman friends, or rather acquaintenances, are so into Botox, suctions of this and that, and tucks and removing of deposits of age - I believe the whole point of "mankind" has been reduced to "oneself." 

Thanks for listening. 

Hugs,
Lisa.

Posted 6/16/2006 10:54 AM by wegotrhythm Xanga Premium Member - reply

Visit thereluctantsinger's Xanga Site!
wegotrhythm: You are correct. Love for one's fellow man is not that high on the list. I must have been dozing off when I wrote that.
Posted 6/16/2006 5:50 PM by thereluctantsinger - reply


Choose Identity
(?)
 
Give eProps (?)
Post a Comment
Add Link | Preview HTML comment help 
Profile Pic:
Default  |  Choose »  (?)



Back to thereluctantsinger's Xanga Site!
Note: your comment will appear in thereluctantsinger's local time zone:
GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)
-->