Conjectures of a guilty bystander-- Merton
About this Entry
Posted by: upsidedownkingdom

Visit upsidedownkingdom's Xanga Site

Original: 4/21/2008 12:07 PM
Comments: 5
eProps: 6

Read Comments
Post a Comment
Back to Your Xanga Site


Who gave the eProps?
2 eProps!2 eProps! 2 eProps from:
Laserlawyer
SurFishy_da_Squishy
TheFlowerDoctor


Monday, April 21, 2008
 
Currently Listening
Heat
By Oscar Lopez
see related

Obama's "bitter" comment

I'm not going to spend much time defending Obama's recent comment in San Francisco about how many people "cling to guns and religion" because of problems in their lives. I think it was a silly thing to say politically, especially considering how the media was going to construe it (given that it was in San Francisco). But then again, some people do cling to guns and perverted forms of religion when they're filled with fear. It certainly wasn't an altogether outlandish thing to say.

What I really wanted to say, though, was that the public response to this has been so silly. "Oh my God," we seem to collectively say, "Obama's not one of us! He's an elite! He doesn't get us! How dare he?"

To which I'm tempted to say: Duh! The man's in the Senate, and he's running for President! Of course he's not one of us! Why should we be so surprised? Really, the only difference between a man like Barack Obama and George W. Bush is that the latter has gotten really good at playing the "I'm one of you, a simple religious conservative, who can't even say the word 'nuclear' properly" game. For the love of God, though, the man grew up with a silver spoon in his mouth. He's never really risked anything without having a ready safety net. He's never really had to work hard without knowing that his well-connected family would back him up. Pretty much all of our major politicians are to a degree like that.

How 'bout we get used to that fact, and stop acting so surprised when Senator Obama says things like that.
 Posted 4/21/2008 12:07 PM - 5 comments

Give eProps or Post a Comment

5 Comments

Visit Laserlawyer's Xanga Site!
With respect to the elitism accusation, that's too simplistic, Nate. Way too simplistic. You, of all people, should know better. Each politician is unique.

Even "W" actually made his way through business school. And why do you begrudge a man for having a well-connected family prepared to back him up? Is that somehow immoral in your book?

And to over-generalize by claiming that "pretty much all of our politicians are to a degree like that" is such an exercise in cynicism. If you really feel that way, I would invite you to jump into the arena and start making a difference. Have you ever worked for a political candidate? Have you ever been one?

With respect to Obama's "clinging" comment, I suspect that what he was trying to say is that, for many people who face hard times, they find continuing comfort and security in their religion. His references to guns, fair trade, and illegal immigration were odd, except insofar as he was identifying so-called "wedge" issues that have been prominent in recent years. Still, I think too much is being made of this one incident. He was speaking in San Francisco for goodness sake. To please his audience there, he could have said far more outrageous things than that.

Frankly, I think Obama's voting record is more disturbing than any of the associational smearing going on right now.
Posted 4/21/2008 1:54 PM by Laserlawyer Xanga True Member - reply

Visit upsidedownkingdom's Xanga Site!
Every politician is unique, yes, but when you get to the national level they seem to become more and more homogenous. That's what I was talking about, by the way: national politicians. I should have said that.

I do try to make a difference, but for most people running for office isn't the way to do that. I think a lot of people run for national office hoping to make a difference, and after a few years they become part of the "system".

It's hardly accurate to say that President Bush "made his way through business school". The man was never more than an average student, yet he kept moving on to bigger and better things. Besides being rescued from bad grades (remember when he famously said "I'm proof that you can get a C average and still become President"?), he was rescued from going to Vietnam, and was saved from multiple bad business investments. Just for the record, no, I don't begrudge him his connections, nor do I think it's immoral. I was only saying that the President is a master at playing the "workin' man" image even though he was born with a silver spoon in his mouth. I was making the ironic point that although he is far more priveleged than Obama, he manages to come off as far less elite.
Posted 4/21/2008 7:18 PM by upsidedownkingdom - reply

Visit Laserlawyer's Xanga Site!
I grant you the point. W comes off as far less of an elitist than Obama. But that may be because he really is less elitist. Have you seen his house in Texas? Compare that with the one being built for Obama's pastor.
Posted 4/21/2008 7:53 PM by Laserlawyer Xanga True Member - reply

Visit SurFishy_da_Squishy's Xanga Site!
I really hate to point this out on an otherwise great blog, but the variant pronunciation of "nuclear" is an accepted and widespread form. See: http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/nuclear
Posted 4/21/2008 8:37 PM by SurFishy_da_Squishy - reply

Visit TheFlowerDoctor's Xanga Site!
It's a shame that 'politics is still POLITICS', even when one doesn't want to play the game. I totally respect Senator Obama for trying to be above/better than this stupid political bickering. Does that, too; make him elitist? What is so wrong with speaking your mind? Obama was totally correct about 'middle America' and the more important point was...people have more self-esteem and are more 'open-minded' when they have jobs! All anyone has to do is look at the mindset of people in the later 90's (when everyone was working) and the mindset of the last several years (when many in the Midwest are not working). It is not rocket science. Huge 'blame games' are being played over and over daily here in Michigan. And finally, spoiled little boy GWB; despite his down on the farm personification, never had to work a day of his life! Let's not kid ourselves here. On the other hand, coming from Obama's background and building a presidency from the ground (streets) on up......is truly, the American way!    
Posted 5/3/2008 4:04 PM by TheFlowerDoctor Xanga Premium Member - reply


Choose Identity
(?)
 
Give eProps (?)
Post a Comment
Add Link | Preview HTML comment help 
Profile Pic:
Default  |  Choose »  (?)



Back to upsidedownkingdom's Xanga Site!
Note: your comment will appear in upsidedownkingdom's local time zone:
GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)